Current at

„We extract thermal energy, not water” – this is the contractor's response to criticism of the giant project in Zugló.

Published

Attila Balázs, owner of Bayer Construct, responded to Index's enquiry by providing detailed information about the Zenit Corso geothermal heating system in Zugló, the claims made in the Népszava article, and presented the most important elements of the technology.

As we have written about several times, the Bayer Construct investment and construction project, the Zenit by Bayer was built as Zugló's new office and commercial hub with a number of forward-looking solutions, such as geothermal heating and the systematic use of prefabrication. In recent weeks, however, a politically charged debate has arisen around geothermal energy, primarily concerning technical issues. To clarify this, interview with Attila Balázs, owner of Bayer Construct. The main points of the article are summarised below.

 

 

False statements were also made.

„We do not tap into the water resources, we extract thermal energy from the thermal water,” – responded Attila Balázs in an interview with Index in response to a statement in an article published by Népszava article in an interview with Index. According to the newspaper, the geothermal investment would affect the thermal water resources beneath the city.

An article in Népszava on 28 October points out that „the office complex purchased by the government for HUF 244 billion, where several ministry departments, NAV and the State Audit Office would move in the coming months, may be left without heating and hot water, while the shopping centre has already been opened”. Their claim was based on the fact that the geothermal system had not received an environmental permit. They also suspected that the water supply to Budapest's thermal baths would be at risk.

However, in response to Index's enquiry, the owner of Bayer Construct explained that the criticisms were professionally incomprehensible and unfounded, adding that there would be hot water and heating in the office complex. He then gave a detailed explanation of how a geothermal system actually works.

 

 

They take heat, not water 

According to Attila Balázs, the biggest misconception is that many people believe that geothermal systems permanently extract water from thermal karst.

„With the technology we use, we do not permanently extract a single drop of water from the thermal karst water bodies located under the capital city.”

– he emphasised, then explained: „In contrast, spas really only use the extracted thermal water once, after which it is discharged into surface watercourses and other designated receiving areas, and this method does indeed cause a continuous decline in the water reserves of the underground layers.”

The geothermal technology in Zugló forms a closed system: we drill a thermal well, extract the thermal water through it, extract the thermal energy using a heat exchanger, and then return the extracted thermal water through a closed network of pipes, pressing it back to the same depth and soil layer.

„What we are actually extracting here is the thermal energy carried by the thermal water, which originates from the Earth's magma, not the water itself, which is returned to its original environment,” explained the company owner.

 

According to an international study, geothermal energy will suffice for millions of years 

Attila Balázs also mentioned that according to an international study, if all of the world's energy were obtained from geothermal sources, the magma would cool by only 0.000015 degrees Celsius (15 microdegrees) in 100 years.

„The professional study referred to by critics of the Zugló investment is based solely on theories and model calculations, without any new measurements, research or investigations. In any case, it is impossible to take accurate seismic measurements in Budapest and other urban environments due to constant background noise and vibrations, so the study provides more of a regional overview and cannot be applied to specific locations,” explained the company executive. According to him, this is why online monitoring systems are needed, which will provide real data on what is happening underground.

During eight days of testing at wells drilled in Zugló, no measurable change was observed in the water levels of surrounding wells.

 

 

This is how the heating system of the Zugló office complex works

After this, he asked Attila Balázs of Index about the actual situation regarding the geothermal system of the Zugló project, which, according to Népszava, had not received an environmental permit.

The energy supply of the buildings is not only based on geothermal technology, but an air-to-air heat pump system also operates in the facility complex, which, without geothermal energy and completely independently of it, provides 100 per cent of the heating and cooling for the buildings and produces hot water for domestic use.

– he stated emphatically, noting that the heat pump solution represents a fully-fledged alternative energy and building engineering construction. „All official permits are in place for the installation of the geothermal system, including the production and reinjection wells and the technological equipment, regardless of what some people may claim.”.

He explained that the permits required for operational use and the necessary official contracts are currently being finalised, with the Pest County Government Office issuing the environmental permit for the geothermal system representing a significant step forward. At the same time, the licensing process for the thermal wells of the new residential area planned next to the Pólus Centre, called Szilas Liget, in District XV, which will also be heated using geothermal energy, is also progressing well.

 

The entire process takes one and a half to two years.

When asked about the licensing process for geothermal systems, Attila Balázs presented a detailed outline of the process:

  • First, a research permit must be obtained from the Regulatory Activities Supervisory Authority (SZTFH), which involves demarcating a larger area, and this also requires the approval of the water management authority.
  • The next step is to obtain a permit for the construction of the wells – a separate permit must be obtained for each well and for the connecting pipeline.
  • After that, various professional tests are carried out, and then the final research report and the application for the designation of a protective area must be submitted.
  • At the same time, you must apply for a usage permit, which requires an environmental permit – this may be preliminary test documentation or an environmental impact assessment.
  • Finally, a utilisation agreement must be concluded with the Ministry of Energy.

The entire process takes at least one and a half, but more likely two years.

 

 

The red zone, which does not mean a ban after all 

We also asked the head of Bayer Construct for information about the so-called red zone designated by SZTFH, which critics refer to. Attila Balázs explained that if the authority designates a red zone and then the same authority issues a permit, it is because it can do so legally and considers it appropriate from a technical and professional point of view.

„The authority designating the so-called »red zone« is the same administrative body that issued the permit.”

– he stated, adding that the SZTFH study is not a piece of legislation, but rather a professional guideline that does not contain any binding prohibitions. The study urges caution, but does not impose prohibitions – it merely makes recommendations. Furthermore, when the study was published, the wells in Zugló already had research and drilling permits, so it could not be applied to them retroactively.

 

More expensive, but pays off in the long run

We also inquired about the business aspects with the investor, specifically about how much more expensive this green solution is compared to traditional heating methods. Attila Balázs was honest in his response:

„It's even more expensive today, we're not making any money on it.”

Implementation costs significantly more than if the energy source were taken from a ready-made pipeline. „However, it pays off in the long run, and what's more, environmental considerations are no longer abstract, negligible tasks, but rather practical challenges that are absolutely essential to address,” says Attila Balázs.

Although previous regulations did not require the reinjection of water extracted in Zugló, they decided to build a reinjection well on their own initiative, as this would make the energy source truly renewable. District heating is currently the cheapest form of heating in Hungary, and if it is supplied by geothermal energy instead of gas, it is an even more efficient and environmentally friendly solution.

„It is very important to highlight a rarely mentioned fact about the Zugló investment: the majority of the thermal energy generated by the geothermal system implemented here (more than 50 per cent) will not be used to serve the facilities in Bosnyák Square – residential buildings, office buildings and commercial centres – but will provide renewable »green energy« for Budapest's district heating system. Under our cooperation agreement with BKM Zrt. (BKM Budapesti Közművek Nonprofit Zrt. – ed.), we have undertaken to transfer the majority of the heat generated here to the district heating provider, which shows that, from a purely professional point of view, this geothermal system is also beneficial and supportable for the capital city.”

 

Source Link

Popular